Thanks for responding! We are using the clicker to teach him to ring the bell.(maybe a bad choice) He is in the crate if we are not home during the day. At night we found better success with him sleeping in bed with us. I use nature’s miracle to clean and have all hardwood and vinyl in the house. I do know beagles can be stubborn but am just wondering if it’s too soon to expect too much from his bladder and control. He has learned to sit, lay down and shake since we started following your clicker training 😊 The potty training is starting to seem impossible.